Skip to content

Utility trucks, fob pockets, ticket pockets and bloodstains revisited.

Professor Cleland wrote a few notes on a copy of a report (see link) he had made to the Coroner and in the first paragraph he mentions he had frequent consultations with DS Leane and visited the site where the body was found with him as well as accompanying Leane to view the case exhibits and the body. Cleland also interviewed and discussed the case with Dr Dwyer, Mr Cowan, Sir Stanton Hicks, Mr Lipaham (lecturer in pharmacy), Dr Poynton and others. In other words Cleland covered the case as thoroughly as you would expect from a man of his distinction and reputation, not to mention that he was previously reported to have assisted in over 700 inquests.

The formal report itself contains a few surprises and two of them have to do with pockets.

The Fob Pocket.

Cleland writes that ‘in an easily-overlooked small money pocket on the right side of the front of the trousers was a small piece of paper  .. etc’ (Gordon Cramer please note.)

The Ticket Pocket.

Cleaned writes and I’ve condensed ..  ‘found in Webb’s ticket pocket were his ticket to St Leonards and a ticket to Henley Beach.’

The Ticket Pocket – Bond Suits

external ticket pocket with flap, other ticket pockets appeared as a slit and that may have been why whoever stripped the body of ID and money etc missed  finding the tickets.

However the most remarkable surprises can be read in Cleland’s scrawled notes  .. these matters have been discussed previously here and there I’m told but I must have missed that particular bus.

Bloodstains on Webb’s Clothing.

Sandra P. van Tongeron writes on DA’s FB site : “Concerning the above notes (see link at end of post), it is curious why they did not follow up on the poison theory by checking the body for wounds on the place of said blood stains on the clothing (in the neck of the suit and on the shirt near a tear, as is mentioned in the above notes) or analyse the black powder (if I correctly recall from another document). If one is stabbed/sliced in the neck, one reaches for the afflicted area which may result in defensive cuts/scratches on the back of the hand, as also described.”

Abbott’s response:

Ok those are Burt Cleland’s personal notes to self I found in an archive over 10 yrs ago.”

And not surprisingly, Professor Abbott made little mention if it. None in fact.

It helps to note that SM was wearing a pullover and coat over the bloodstained shirt, add to that Dwyer didn’t notice any wounds on the body that would account for the bloodstains.

~~

The Utility Truck.

1948 Fargo DeLuxe Utility (Australia) | Chrysler Australia L… | Flickr

From page 9 of the file, dated 5/5/70.

“A mutilated copy of Omar K found thrown into the back of a utility truck in Glenelg … etc”

Mutilated we’re ok with, sort of, if that’s what you’d call a book with a small square torn out of the last page.

~~

There you have it, and I’m not going to start a bonfire by giving Gerry Feltus and his Chemist Freeman explanation any criticism as he was almost wholly dependant on hearsay with his account of the circumstances of SM’s death and the finding of the Rubaiyat. However, I doubt Professor Cleland would be easily duped, though it would help if he had noted who gave him the utility information so late in the piece.

~~

So, make of them what you will.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1yFWG-kelPmm4mzHIoE8Xn8vqGD0Uj5Vj/view?fbclid=IwAR2War_bw-JeK3Gp5QkUFehmd7juvcltiLHC_xO-On2M8jtvRnrsa3hB_0U

26 Comments Post a comment
  1. John Sanders #

    Here we have Clelands hand written notes as per link, ‘Stain with blood on back of neck of? shirt (No stains on coat) … ? from slab etc’….which stand on their own merits without need for the usual enticing enhancements. A fairly common misconception regarding SM’s shirt, be that its collar was a detachable job and there was a spare in the suitcase from memory.

    Like

    April 21, 2024
    • Sounds like a lot of contamination right there, DNA wise.

      Like

      April 21, 2024
  2. Calypso #

    You really need to take a closer look. There are TWO notes about the blood-coloured stain. You seem to overlook the second note he wrote with more details on the stain in exhibit C, which apparently answers the questions he had about it in the first note in exhibit A (exhibits are marked A-D in the upper right corners).

    References to this in the notes included with the report to the coroner:

    In exhibit A:

    “Stain … blood in back of neck of shirt. (No stain in coat). ? from slab. Who undressed him?”

    In exhibit C:

    “Shirt – large blood-tinted stain in arch of shirt near tip on one side only of a tear

    Either or both of these notes/observations have been overlooked from day one, and apparently still are. Whilst it was ruled to have been a poisoning, wounds to the skin and the blood-coloured stain on the shirt as a means of poison administration were completely overlooked in the CI. DA apparently overlooked the notes too, amongst other things, believing that Carl W. must have committed suicide.

    P.S. You’ve misspelled her name.

    Like

    April 21, 2024
    • John Sanders #

      Wasn’t it Sandra von whatsit or one of them who thought Carl might’ve nicked himself shaving. Could be on the money but for the ‘Charlie’ part. Some will recall what a bitch it was to remove blood stains from our shirt collars, especially on the road.

      Like

      April 22, 2024
    • Calypso #

      The pathologist may indeed have dismissed a nick in the neck as a razor burn, my dear Watson.

      However, the blood-coloured stain in the shirt on closer inspection was apparently on one side of a tear only. This particular characteristic of the stain is crucial, and can be used to figure out its cause. IMO the stained tear in combination with the hand abrasions should have been thoroughly investigated and reported at the time, especially as a possible means of poison administration: photograph it, cut it out, have it tested for blood and poison, and swab the wounds on the hand for poison as well.

      As for now, for discussion’s sake, it seems unlikely to cause a tear in the back of the neck of the arch of one’s shirt whilst shaving. Moreover, most have their shirts off whilst shaving in the first place. A photograph would have been useful to show the exact location, since it having been in the back of the neck AND near the tip seems contradicting.

      As for the identification of Carl W., that’s the coroner’s call. I’d say call him, if you know better.

      Like

      April 23, 2024
      • Bloodstains on his shirt, abrasions between his knuckles? The bloke had been in a fight is my view, and the blood belonged to the other fellow.

        Like

        April 23, 2024
  3. At least we agree on one thing Calypso, not everything is as has long been understood .. and for that we can only blame Professor Abbott who cherry picked what he wanted and wilfully ignored what mattered.

    Like

    April 21, 2024
  4. No One - It's corrupt #

    Adelaide’s run by a corrupt government

    Good luck

    Like

    April 22, 2024
    • What can I say: my home state NSW has had more than its share of corrupt Premiers, Ministers, Police Chiefs, senior detectives, magistrates, public servants, judges, lobbyists, councillors, mayors, developers, lawyers ..

      Like

      April 22, 2024
      • Clive #

        Just get the feeling that this was 1949 I.e. a few short yrs after WW2, and people were trying to re-build their lives. Probably, this case was regarded as another ‘John Doe’ and things that didn’t match were of little concern?

        Like

        April 22, 2024
        • Yeah, but how come there was no photo of the Rubaiyat, and none of the back cover containing the code, and why Naval Intelligence weren’t given the opportunity to see if the code matched the content in the original book .. Cramer would have a field day with his micro-code if that was the case.

          Like

          April 22, 2024
  5. john sanders #

    Quite a few years back I had on CM I mooted that the TS slip could easily have been concealed in the vacated gusset lining of SM’s Stamina exacto-fit war model trousers. Off course that’s where GC took the idea from, and then with some minor input ie. “waist band” sans my gusset lining, he published as is his wont. I’m not complaining that he stole the idea nor that he forgot the heads up.

    Like

    April 22, 2024
  6. No One - govt crime #

    and the Registrar-General in the Lands Titles Office. In South Australia at least. It’s all there on the land Register. Just help yourself when you’re a public servant or get paid off to steal properties for others by false records on the Register. Those old Register Books are just riddled with their crimes. What’s the quickest way to wealth Property. What’s the quickest way to get it. Steal it by false entries on the Torrens Register and when you have done it you get a good title by the curtain principle. The perfect crime facilitated by the government itself

    Like

    April 22, 2024
  7. Calypso #

    FYI, there’s more written about the pocket the TS slip was kept in in the same notes (exhibit c), included with the report to the coroner:

    Piece of paper … Tamám Shud in small .. trouser pocket – or fly

    Like

    April 23, 2024
    • Calypso #

      Gordon just wrote a truth or dare question on his blog:

      “A thought that may help in relation to the torn slip and its hiding place in the fob pocket.
      If you imagine that the Somerton Man was standing facing you and he was wearing his white shirt and tie, the trousers he was wearing when his body was found, the woolen socks (with the well darned heel) and his stockman’s tan coloured shoes.
      Would you be able to see the opening of the fob pocket that contained the hidden torn slip in his trousers?”

      Answer: Going by the notes, apparently the pocket was located somewhere near the fly. I’d be looking in that direction for sure but would not be able to think straight anymore. So no, I would not be able to see the opening of the pocket. Does that answer the question?

      Like

      April 23, 2024
  8. John Sanders #

    Pathologist Dwyer described abrasions between two knucle hollows in the right hand as being insignificant and he found no evidence of likely puncture sites.for injection of curare & c.

    Like

    April 23, 2024
    • Be nice to know if PT got a black eye out of it.

      Like

      April 23, 2024
    • Calypso #

      There are a number of extremely toxic poisons that can kill through mere contact with the skin/scratches alone. Severe poisoning may be experienced especially by the poison entering the bloodstream or near the carotid artery. Remember where the bloodstained tear was located. Since time immemorial poisons such as the well-known curare have been used for hunting or warfare by applying the poison to an arrow or blade. Therefore the method of poison administration by a blade should be a serious consideration.

      Remember, Prof. CS Hicks suggested the arrow poison ouabain during the CI.

      Like

      April 23, 2024
      • Fair enough, but now we become enmeshed with Cramer’s atomic spy hypothesis.. and his insistence on micro-coding.

        Like

        April 23, 2024
    • John Sanders #

      Well yes. Sir C. Stanton Hicks would have known a thing or two about exotic poisins, he being chief food ration adviser for AIF land forces during WW2 (Colonel). Check his AB, ‘Who Called the Cook a Runt’ alt. ‘Who called the Runt a Cook.

      Like

      April 24, 2024
  9. John Sanders #

    I seem to recall mention of Prosper being at Fisheman’s Bend for the Holden release a day or two before SM’s trip to town.

    Like

    April 23, 2024
    • Clive #

      Would it be possible that Prosper returned from Fisherman’s Bend with a certain pax.

      Like

      April 24, 2024
  10. John Sanders #

    Clive,

    Indeed, indeed. especially in that Jessie and baby Robin were with him according to the gen. If they had travelled back home from Melbourne together on the Overlander or else met SM onboard then things start to fall into place, eg., the pocket ROK hand over and advice from locals on what he might like to do in Adelaide. This cute angle was posited by a CM poster in greater detail some years ago but, for some reason it was not taken further.

    Like

    April 24, 2024
  11. John Sanders #

    Just a hunch Clive but might I put forward a case for Jessie having jotted her number down in tiny writing on the pocket ROKet and slipping it to SM while Prosper was going through his kit in the luggage compartment.

    Like

    April 25, 2024
  12. Clive #

    Especially if Jessie, alias ‘Mrs Thomson’, took a shine to SM?

    Like

    April 25, 2024
  13. Clive #

    A shine that Prosper wouldn’t/couldn’t forget so……

    Like

    April 27, 2024

Leave a reply to Calypso Cancel reply