Skip to content

What powers does a coroner have?

Did Coroner Cleland have the power to depose a witness despite the objections of the local police?

7 Comments Post a comment
  1. I’ve asked the same question to SteveH over at CM … perhaps he could try Google AI for assistance, I’ve already done that and am happy to report that we might have a new can of worms to deal with.

    Like

    February 4, 2026
  2. dusty #

    Simply put Pete, the SA Coroner has the broadest of powers with regard to hear evidence related to deaths & suspected deaths of persons where some doubts be raised as to how, when, where and why. They can direct police inquiries as to a particular line of interest they perceive to be important and their authority cannot to be overuled by any other power. In the case of Somerton Man, Coroner Cleland appointed PCC John Sutherland to be his SAPOL link to the Investigation and he stayed on the case from go to woa ie. Officer Sutherland was at the assumed death scene on day one, and was the last person to see Jerry before his coffin lid was sealed pre burial at West Terrrace cemetery. Scan the man was one of the pall bearers and there’s no doubting his dedication to coronial duties expected of him.

    Like

    February 4, 2026
    • PCC = Plain Clothes Constable, right? So what is this oath you mentioned?

      Like

      February 4, 2026
  3. dusty #

    Guess pledge would be a more fitting appication to the matter in question, sans ‘Sworn on a bible Oath. That be what Feltus terms was a pact of witness identity non disclosure, one made between Det. R.Leane and hi sinformants John Freeman and Jessica Thomson at the time, as you’ll recall from the histerical novel.

    Like

    February 4, 2026
    • Pledge: – a (guessed) solemn promise or undertaking made by a police constable .. hardly legal you reckon? Enough to overcome the coroner’s intentions?

      Like

      February 4, 2026
  4. dusty #

    Absolutely Peteb. Happens all the time when investigations are incomplete; the coroner is most likely to agree to give police an extended time waiver which includes concealing the identities of witnesses with potentially case closing evidence.

    Like

    February 4, 2026
    • This investigation was nowhere near incomplete, given the overwhelming new evidence and knowledge of crucial witnesses.

      Like

      February 4, 2026

Leave a comment