Skip to content

The Hat 2- The man sitting in the corner of the bar, watching.

1944 / 45 .. Sydney, a hotel by the harbour frequented by service personnel involved in managing the passage of shipping both naval and merchant in and out of the boom that stretched from one side of the harbour to the other whether it be done in broad daylight for all to see or in the darkness of a blacked-out night for none to see.

And there, sitting prettily amongst the older regulars is a twenty-something young lady.

Security Services in those distant days are often ridiculed by those who know better these days – but we weren’t there to see the man sitting in the corner of the bar watching the young woman chatting to the older men and the only reason the man was there was because he had been trained to seek out and watch such gatherings, or rather this type of gathering given the nature and situation of the mens’ work and knowing that Sydney had much more to offer a young unmarried woman who liked to socialise, particularly with all the Americans around. But here she was.

So he watched who she talked to and as time went by a couple of his female colleagues took turns in following her when she wasn’t working, seeing who else she might be meeting regularly then following them around. Some of these individuals she met in city hotel lobbies, others in parks churches and cemeteries and here grew more suspicion as she was never observed to visit them in their homes. The question was asked: if they weren’t her friends then what were they?

Her file grew.

She fell pregnant. She moved to Melbourne. Then to Adelaide.

And so did one of the men she used to meet regularly in parks churches and cemeteries

His file grew.

 

 

 

13 Comments Post a comment
  1. Clive #

    The same man who wrote to her via her parents address in Melbourne? So, before she left Sydney for Melbourne, for the man to be able to contact her, she must have given him her parents address? Was Prosper aware of this letter, and if so, perhaps an incentive for a new start in SA?

    Like

    September 14, 2023
    • Perhaps he didn’t contact her at all after Sydney. The thick will plotten Clive.

      Like

      September 14, 2023
  2. Guzz Rating #

    Totally off the subject of this thread, but this article just popped up on Daily Mail website.

    https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12528299/Somerton-Man-Twist-Australias-mysterious-cold-cases-case-bizarre-birthday-card-emerges.html

    Who’s Carl Josef Halban? Has that name ever cropped up before???

    Like

    September 18, 2023
    • a lurker #

      has had a mention on BigFooty (November ’22)

      Like

      September 18, 2023
    • a lurker #

      The site it originally comes from is currently down, but can be found on the wayback machine (deathatsomerton.com.au)

      Like

      September 18, 2023
    • a lurker #

      sorry to spam…..I’d be inclined to dismiss it based on photos of Halban appearing like he was seriously balding…

      Like

      September 18, 2023
  3. No One #

    No facial furrows on Halban. His nostrils also don’t match
    The photo of Somerton man is an overlay using Boxall’s face
    so nobody’s face will ever match it. Only Boxall himself.
    Which is the face that Jess recognised.
    Women are good at noticing distinguishing features quickly
    So she saw him immediately from the Clifton Gardens pub days
    It’s likely his fingerprints were used too,
    so nobody’s fingerprints will ever match those either.
    Body swaps, face swaps, fingerprint swaps
    Pretty good work for 1948
    They probably didn’t realise all the attention it would get
    It was just a man who died on the beach and that’s the end of it
    Except he carried a recognition signal with him
    The rolled up Tamam Shud which created a trace
    They didn’t see that coming
    Apart from that pretty good spy work and cover up

    Like

    September 18, 2023
    • Guzz Rating #

      @ No One…

      But why would they try to use Boxall’s face and fingerprints when the guy was still alive? Couldn’t they have just used another dead body?

      Like

      September 18, 2023
      • No One #

        Your comment doesn’t make sense

        Like

        September 19, 2023
        • Guzz rating #

          No…your comment makes no sense…

          “The photo of Somerton man is an overlay using Boxall’s face
          so nobody’s face will ever match it. Only Boxall himself.
          Which is the face that Jess recognised.
          Women are good at noticing distinguishing features quickly
          So she saw him immediately from the Clifton Gardens pub days
          It’s likely his fingerprints were used too,
          so nobody’s fingerprints will ever match those either.”

          Why would they use the face and fingerprints of someone who could demonstrably be proved to still be alive…and was!

          Like

          September 20, 2023
          • No One #

            They did because they could get away with it
            It almost came apart when Jess revealed Boxall
            Which she did to say I’m on the team so leave me alone
            So they hid her identity from the public
            Boxall was way in the background by then
            and his fingerprints not on police file
            Pretty good charade they all kept up
            Performance acting deserving of an Academy Award

            Like

            September 21, 2023
  4. No One #

    No
    Because using another dead body, it could be identified from fingerprint records
    Then the jig is up
    So they used Boxall

    Like

    September 19, 2023
  5. Clive #

    I’m certain that Carl J. Halban isn’t SM. However, reading the series of notes on the NAA site, it’s interesting that he seemed to have been able to arrive in Australia as a refugee, leave Australia and return. His occupation is described as a ‘Milliner Designer’ no idea how he managed to afford to travel across the globe with his wife. Never realised how lucrative designing hats was!

    Like

    April 3, 2024

Leave a reply to Clive Cancel reply