Skip to content

Posts from the ‘Uncategorized’ Category

CH 8 – When is a Spy no longer a Spy?

The bloke was just a bloody suburban electrical fitter, an instrument maker plus he had an addiction to phenobarbital with ether on the side which is not unlike someone liking hashish with a straight malt whisky chaser.

Read more

CH 7 – The Train Ticket Nobody Noticed

Another look at what didn’t happen

Read more

Sir Frederick Geoffrey Shedden (KCMG, OBE) – Secretary of the Dept. of Defence and his chauffeur : ex bus-driver Frederick Norman Webb. Charlie (Carl ) Webb’s nephew.

Sir Frederick Geoffrey Shedden (KCMG, OBE): The Secretary of the Department of Defence

and his personal chauffeur …. Fredrick Norman Webb, former bus driver.

Details of Webb’s NAA file

24 August 1944. Webb, aged 23, has his Oath or Affirmation to join the RAAF filed as incomplete in that his name is missing, the form not signed and the Oath not completed.

4th September 1944. Webb’s Cancellation of Exemption From Service In The Defence Force filed as complete.

19 September 1944. Webb’s application to join the RAAF filed as complete.

20th September 1944. Webb’s Personal Particulars of Recruits form filed as complete.

20th September 1944. Webb’s application for recruitment into the Citizen Air Force prior to his enlistment filed as complete.

5th November 1947. Webb’s Application For Discharge filed as complete.

As noted in his file, Webb was Sir Frederick Geoffrey Shedden’s (KCMG, OBE) personal driver.

Shedden was the Secretary of the Department of Defence from 1937 to 1956 and in 1940 was appointed to the Advisory War Council.

“Shedden was a tough, shrewd operator who spent his whole career at Victoria barracks in Melbourne (refusing to move to Canberra). Shedden’s biographer, David Horner, cites a description of Shedden as a powerful personality who was ‘ruthless with those who crossed him, and devastating with those … who could not rise to his exceptional standards of performance”. The Strategist

-John Edwards describes Shedden’s ill humour when sailing with Prime Minister John Curtin to the US in 1944:

“The voyage across the Pacific to San Francisco took two weeks. Separated from his files, from his department, from his independence and authority as the bureaucratic overlord of the national war effort, Shedden was morose. Files were knowledge, and knowledge was power. A habitual note taker, he was suddenly bereft of content.”

~~

If it was learnt during the investigation of the mysterious death of Carl Webb that Shedden was in some way innocently implicated in the spying business of the day, whether through carelessness with securing his files (or notes) or being too open in conversation with a colleague whilst being driven by his personal chauffeur (Carl Webb’s nephew Norman) then little wonder the police investigation appeared to be less thorough as you would expect and what was thought to have been their carelessness may have in fact been deliberate. The fact that detective Brown was denied any part of the investigation after the Rubaiyat was allegedly handed in might indicate he initially wasn’t trusted to be party to the scheme, though he was later rewarded with a promotion to detective inspector, which may have been the result of trust restored.

What’s more it could explain the absence of any photo of what was thought to have been Carl Webb’s Rubaiyat, together with the sudden appearance of the Tamam Shud slip some weeks after the body’s clothing was searched and later the hastily scrawled code thought to have been written by Webb was discovered on the book’s back cover, which in itself implied some type of espionage activity afoot. And to take the hypothesis even further you might think the visit by the police to Jessica’s home and her subsequent visit to view the bust were orchestrated to demonstrate the police’s knowledge of her relationship with Norman Webb’s uncle, himself thought to have been a spy and remembering that no photograph of her phone number – said to have been written on the back of the book and which led the police to her door – has ever been made public.

Little wonder Jessica remained silent for all her remaining years and not surprisingly her daughter Kate said when interviewed she had ‘a dark side’ to her nature.

And little wonder Dr Dwyer stated that he was ‘astounded’ no traces of barbiturate were discovered in the body by analyst Cowan, who coincidentally was present when Professor Cleland discovered the TS slip in the fob pocket of the trousers being worn by Webb.

And who proved to be unable to identify the black powder shaken from a simple particle brush found in Webb’s suitcase, which was left unlocked at the luggage office.

Which might explain why DS Leane didn’t investigate the train ticket found in Webb’s ticket pocket the day it was found … because who knows? If the police had of asked railway staff to describe the individual who lodged the bag on the day after the body was found their recollection may have been of someone who looked completely different.

 

You know it makes sense.

CH 5 – Implications. Walls and cars have ears ..

.. and food for thought

Read more

CH 4 – Jestyn

She would miss him.

Read more

CH 3 – The Army Lieutenant

A jug of bread and a loaf of wine.

Read more

CH 2 – The Cadre

Commit nothing to paper. Ever.

Read more

CH 1 – The Nurse

'The writer may very well serve a moment of history as its mouthpiece, but he cannot of course create it.'

Read more

An introduction to what comes next

It's about time somebody put it all together, again ...

Read more

25 – Atomic Weapons Research and a Dead Man’s Slippers.

3 of 3.

Robert James Cowan’s travel manifest (below) shows he was sponsored to America in 1940/41* by Paul Leland Kirk, a key participant in the Manhattan Project who was working at the university of California at Berkeley. J. Robert Oppenheimer’s work in the same University and on the same project came to fruition in 1945 and Cowan was given 10 months in their lab to get onboard with the American nuclear developments … yet here he is in 1949 trying on a random dead man’s old slippers at the same time Professor Cleland found what looked to be a suicide note in the unfortunate fellow’s fob pocket.

*J Sanders for the correction

24 – The Particle Brush and J. Robert Oppenheimer.

Now we have three choices.

Read more

23 – PC Moss: The Bravest Man In The Station

But that's not the end of it because when the Professor Cleland found the slip he was in the company of James Cowan.

Read more

22 – A Codebreaker’s Quandary

If nothing else this beats trying to convince the few remaining Somerton Man punters that Carl Webb looks to be the same height as his much shorter brother.

Read more

21 – Carl Webb was a violent drug addict and suicidal wife beater

The smell of ether was so strong that other tenants complained. I found empty bottles and after a struggle got him to tell me what else he had taken, namely 40 Phenobarbitel tablets.

Read more

20 – The end of the game.

Now we wait.

Read more

19 – An Investigation Bound To Fail.

Try putting this jigsaw together.

Read more

17 – A Dead Man’s Hair

As fragile as spun glass

Read more

16 – A little provenance is required before we decide upon anything rash

As Professor Derek Abbott and the drop dead gorgeous Fiona of the Antiques Roadshow insist - provenance is everything.

Read more

15 – The suicidal electrical fitter ..

...with the physique of a body-builder

Read more

14 – Never a man to run from a camera

Smile

Read more

13 – Believe it or else …

… Two siblings carefully seperate two pages of a photograph album that has been stuck together for what, nearly seventy years? More? Ninety?


And here, almost pristine in appearance is an ancient ink-labelled photo that has defied both the deterioration of time and the unsticking of itself from the page it has been joined to for longer than anyone reading this, bar me.

12 – Reasonable doubt.

Never mind that Roy Webb on the right appears to be about the same height as Charlie Webb standing between the grandparents, forget that the height difference between the two is officially about three inches, take no notice that both of them are standing within close touching distance of said grandparents, heed not that Roy, supposedly the shorter of the two might appear even taller if he stood up straight. Instead, let’s take a look at the old folk.

My guess is that Richard is about three inches taller than his wife Eliza, give or take.

Many argue the reason Charlie appears to be the same height as Roy is that he is further away from the camera and this distance has subsequently reduced his height in comparison to the shorter Roy. Well, there is a rule of thumb guide that can be used to refute such an argument.

How far back from the camera would Richard have stand to appear to be the same height as Eliza?

A metre? Two metres?

Is Charlie standing that far back from Roy?

Of course the assumption here is that the photographer, being an old-fashioned type would have been sure to stand both old folks on a level surface for the pic, not wanting either of them to stumble over uneven ground.

Roy Webb’s enlistment file

You know it makes sense.

11 – I can’t see it.

Carl Webb Aged about 25

 

Carl Webb Aged 43

 

… and still no SAPOL DNA result, 2 years and 2 months on.

https://voshart.com/BIO

 

 

10 – What if it was something else entirely?

The Freeman Rubaiyat wasn't lost.

Read more

9 – What are we looking at here, a slip-shod investigation or something else entirely?

Inexplicable delays in presenting evidence and the apparent loss of same.

Read more