Skip to content

Why would Brown ask someone to match the TS slip and torn page when Feltus was told they fitted each other perfectly?

When Detective Superintendent Brown was interviewed by Stuart Littlemore about his efforts at matching the TS slip with the book it went like this, as accurately transcribed from Littlemore’s notes. It can be noted that Brown didn’t answer Littlemore’s question in the clear manner of a senior detective confident of his ground.

Littlemore: So that was the book belonging to the dead man, presumably?

Brown: Yes well, (clears throat) we established that it was the book er – I took it at the time, to a paper expert in Leigh Street, Adelaide er he was wor* – he was with Julius Combes (phonetic) who was the printers then, and he examined the cutting and also the book and he er – was satisfied that it was the same paper texture and er – the same / and it was, it was, it did come from that particular book.

*working?

Clive was kind enough to chase down what appeared to be the printer’s shop and came up with the following:

Per S & McD directory, 1948-1949, The only Julius in Leigh St was a Julius Cohn, Leather/Grindery Merchant.

From this information it becomes apparent that the ‘paper expert’ was in fact a nameless worker presumably with some knowledge of paper types employed in the leather / grindery business and was possibly an acquaintance of Brown and not, as Professor Abbott recently claimed, a specialist paper analyst based in Leigh Street, Adelaide. 

Then we have the following comment written by Gerry Feltus in his book The Unknown Man, page 172.

“I was also advised (by reliable sources) that the area torn from the actual copy was smaller than that shown in the newspaper photograph, and that the the piece of paper with the words “Tamam Shud” fitted into the torn area perfectly.”

If we believe Feltus and the slip and tear were a perfect fit then there would have been little need for Brown to have the paper types matched.

But if we believe Brown, it appears he was attempting to match the actual slip with the larger tear as pictured below, and given the recent and robust discussions on the validity of hearsay then it looks as though we must believe Brown’s first hand account rather than Feltus’ reliable second-hand sources, and accept the fact that Brown did not have possession of the Freeman Rubaiyat at the time he visited Leigh Street, which could only have been a short time after Freeman allegedly handed it to Detective Sergeant Leane.

Copy of torn page printed in media

“Copy produced in media depicting actual copy of Rubaiyat” (Feltus’ caption)

 

Actual TS slip

Header pic is Detective Superintendent Brown

4 Comments Post a comment
  1. Clive #

    So, I suppose you could ask why all the ‘song and dance’ about finding the Rubaiyat in the back of the car and, being handed over by Freeman, to the police?

    February 5, 2022
    • The most interesting task a man could undertake with regard this mystery, Clive, is not to create a conspiracy to fit the known facts, but to dismantle the conspiracy we suspect already exists.
      If you could imagine the truth as being hidden behind a wall of bricks and each brick is an integral factor of the conspiracy, then all we have to do is dislodge one of them to eventually bring down the lot.

      And who knows, maybe these last couple of posts are the start of the process.

      February 5, 2022
  2. Clive #

    As an aside, the “News (Adelaide)” dated 14 Jan 1947 reported that a Colin Charles Freeman, chemist, Jetty Road, Glenelg had a breaking at his house.

    February 7, 2022
  3. Clive #

    Plus, an A. Freeman (Chemist) at 24 Jetty Road, Glenelg, per S & McD (1949)

    February 8, 2022

Leave a Reply to peterbowes Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: