Skip to content

Suicide or Murder.

Thomas Erskine Cleland.

I cannot say.

The evidence is too inconclusive to warrant a finding. There is no evidence as to who the deceased was. Although he died during the night of the 30th November-1st December, I cannot say were he died. I would be prepared to find that he died from poison, that the poison was probably a glucoside and that it was not accidentally administered; but I cannot say whether it was administered by the deceased himself or by some other person.

John Matthew Dwyer L.Q.M.P

Death was not natural.

There was food in the stomach. I would say that the food had been in the stomach for up to 3 or 4 hours before death. It is difficult to give an opinion on that, because if the person is in a state of anxiety, that digestion may be suspended. I have made microscopic examination of the disease, and there was pigment in it, although I cannot say of what disease.

I feel quite certain that the death was not natural. I think the immediate cause of death was heart failure, but I am unable to say what factor caused heart failure.

Robert James Cowan.

Death more likely due to natural causes.

I feel quite satisfied that if the death were caused by any common poison, my examination would have revealed its nature. If he did die from poison, I think it would be a very rare poison. I mean something rarely used for suicidal or homicidal purposes. I cannot make any suggestions as to what that might be. I think that death is more likely to have been due to natural causes than poisoning. I failed to detect any (common) poison in the stomach or organs, and this causes me to make that statement.

Detective Leane.

There is no fact that I know of which points towards suicide and abolishes the possibility of murder.

There is no fact that I know of which points towards suicide and abolishes the possibility of murder. I believe he died an unnatural death, but how I cannot say. A physical specimen as he was would not just go to the beach and die. The words “Taman Shud” mean the end, or the finish. That could have been placed in his pocket by the person who caused his death, so I cannot attach any special significance to that.

Detective Brown.

As far as this death is concerned, there is no context into which the words (Tamam Shud) can fit.

It (the words Tamam Shud meaning To End) does not seem to have any bearing on the case, or any meaning as to the cause of this death. As far as this death is concerned, there is no context into which the words can fit.

John Burton Cleland.

Death was almost certainly not natural, and in all probability that some poison had been taken, with suicidal intent.

I have considered the circumstances disclosed in the evidence, and I came to the opinion, taking all the circumstances into account, that death was almost certainly not natural, and in all probability that some poison had been taken, with suicidal intent. I came to that conclusion before I found the piece of paper bearing the words “Taman shud”. Bearing in mind that those words mean something like “the end” that supports my opinion considerably; I think the words were put there deliberately and indicated that intention that he was fed up with things.

Note: both Detective Leane and Detective Brown agree that the translation of the words Tamam Shud bear no significance to the manner of SM’s death.

 

2 Comments Post a comment
  1. What election ?

    November 4, 2020
    • пожалуйста #

      Here in Yekaterinburg, we are following with bucket of Попкорн.

      I think winner is Vladimir Vladimirovich.

      November 4, 2020

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s